
How to Choose a Klaviyo Agency: 10 Questions to Ask Before You Hire
The ten questions to ask any Klaviyo email and SMS agency before you sign, plus the red flags that tell you to keep looking.
Overview
Most Shopify brands hire a Klaviyo agency for the same reason: email and SMS should be one of their most profitable channels, and it isn’t. The flows are old, the campaigns go out because the calendar says so, and nobody can say with confidence what the program actually earns.
The right agency fixes that. The wrong one sends more emails, reports open rates and locks you into a long contract. These are the ten questions we’d ask before hiring any Klaviyo agency, including us.
1. Who will actually work in our account?
Many agencies sell with senior people and deliver with junior ones. Ask for the names of the people who will build your flows and write your campaigns, and whether they’ll be on your calls. If the answer is an account manager who relays messages to a team you never meet, expect slower work and diluted thinking.
2. What happens in the first 30 days?
A good agency starts with an audit of your flows, campaigns, segments and list health, then gives you a prioritized plan tied to revenue. You should know what launches first and why. Core flow improvements can usually go live within a few weeks, not months.
3. How do you measure success?
Open rates and email volume are activity, not results. Ask how the agency measures incremental revenue, repeat purchase rate, subscriber retention and lifetime value, and how they handle attribution. Klaviyo’s attributed revenue is useful, but an agency that only reports it isn’t telling you what changed.
4. Can you show results for brands like ours?
Ask for specific outcomes from brands with a similar price point, purchase cycle and business model. Subscription, consumables and one-time-purchase brands need very different programs. Vague claims like “we 3x’d revenue” mean little without the starting point and the time frame.
5. How do you protect deliverability?
Every other result depends on reaching the inbox. A strong agency will talk about domain authentication, engagement-based segmentation, sunset flows, list cleaning and how they ramp send volume. If they plan to grow revenue simply by emailing your whole list more often, be careful.
6. Do you run SMS as well as email?
Email and SMS work best as one program, with shared segments and timing so customers aren’t hit twice with the same message. Ask whether the agency builds SMS opt-in, flows and campaigns in Klaviyo, or treats SMS as an add-on.
7. Do you understand subscriptions?
If you sell on subscription through Recharge, Skio or another subscription app, retention is a different problem: onboarding new subscribers, reminders before each charge, failed-payment recovery, cancellation saves and win-back. Ask how the agency connects your subscription data to Klaviyo and which subscription flows they would build first.
8. Who designs the emails?
Ask whether creative is designed in-house for your brand or adapted from templates, and ask to see real examples. Design is where many agencies cut corners, and it’s often what customers notice first.
9. How do you test and report?
Look for a regular testing cadence, clear weekly or monthly reporting, and a fast way to communicate, such as a shared Slack channel. You should always know what was tested, what won and what happens next.
10. What are the contract terms?
Long minimum terms protect the agency, not you. An agency that is confident in its results can usually work month-to-month or with a short initial term. Also ask who owns the flows, templates and data if you part ways. The answer should be you.
Red flags to watch for
Reporting that focuses on opens, clicks and send volume instead of revenue and retention.
No clear answer to who will do the work.
Templated creative that could belong to any brand.
A plan that relies on sending more emails to everyone.
Long lock-in contracts with no performance checkpoints.
How we answer these questions at Bylders
We’re a small, senior team by design. The people on your calls build your flows, campaigns and segments, and we don’t outsource. Every engagement starts with a free growth audit of your Klaviyo account, we launch in about two weeks, and we test and report weekly in a shared Slack channel. Engagements are month-to-month.
Across our clients we’ve managed $750M+ in revenue and lifted repeat purchase rate by 22% on average. If you want the details, see how we run Klaviyo email and SMS for Shopify brands, how we approach subscription retention on any platform, or read about our founder.
Work with Bylders
Want this running in your account?
We’re a small, senior retention team for DTC brands on Klaviyo and subscription platforms like Recharge and Skio. The people who write these guides are the people who run client accounts.
Klaviyo email & SMS
Flows, campaigns, segmentation and SMS for Shopify brands, built and run hands-on.
Learn more →
Subscription retention
Klaviyo and your subscription platform (Recharge, Skio and more) working together: onboarding, churn saves, failed payments and win-back.
Learn more →
Meet the founder
Parker Burr grew the subscription brand FEAT from zero to $50M+ before starting Bylders.
Learn more →







