~20% of skippers made their next shipment.

~20% of skippers made their next shipment.

~75% of discount takers did.

~75% of discount takers did.

Skips Aren’t Saves: Why Your Subscription Churn Rate Looks Better Than It Is

Subscription platforms don’t count a skip or a delay as a cancellation. Here’s why that hides your real churn, what we changed in a client’s cancel flow, and a three-step check you can run today.

Bylders homepage: Turn shoppers into customers, and customers into regulars.
Bylders homepage: Turn shoppers into customers, and customers into regulars.

Overview

Across the subscription brands we run retention for, on Recharge, Skio and other platforms, we kept seeing the same thing: churn rates that looked surprisingly healthy. That sounds like good news. When we dug in, it wasn’t.

Why your churn rate looks better than it is

Subscription platforms don’t count a skip or a delay as a cancellation, because technically it isn’t one. The subscriber is still active. So when your cancel flow’s first offer is “skip your next order,” every subscriber who takes it disappears from your churn number.

But you don’t get that charge either. And in our data, a skip usually wasn’t a save. It was a cancellation on a delay. The subscribers who skipped or delayed were among the most likely to cancel later, and they produced the least revenue afterward.

What the data showed

At one supplement brand on Skio, the cancel flow led with a skip offer. We pulled every subscriber who went through it and tracked what happened next:

  • Only about 20% of subscribers who took the skip made it to their next shipment.

  • About 75% of subscribers who were offered a discount instead made it to their next order.

In other words, a subscriber offered a discount was nearly four times as likely to keep paying as one offered a skip. The discount group was smaller at first, because it was only offered to a few cohorts, but the gap was too big to ignore.

What we changed

We kept the cancel flow’s first screen the same: same video, same copy. We changed one thing. Instead of “skip your next order,” the main action became a discount: 20% off the next two orders.

In the first ten days, reactivated subscribers rose 50% and recovered subscribers rose 40%. Two months later, compared with the previous 30 days, the cancel flow’s save rate was up 26%, saves were up 22% and cancellations were down 10%. Just as important, the churn rate we were reporting started to reflect reality, because skips were no longer hiding cancellations.

Do this today: a three-step check

  1. Look at the save offers in your cancel flow. What’s the first thing a subscriber sees when they try to cancel? If it’s skip, delay or pause, that’s where to start.

  2. Count how many subscribers skip or delay. Pull the number from your subscription platform for the last 60 to 90 days.

  3. See how many of them ever come back. Of the subscribers who skipped or delayed, how many placed their next order, and how many cancelled later? If most of them cancel anyway, the skip isn’t saving them. Lead with a discount instead, and track revenue per subscriber afterward.

A note on keeping cancellation easy

A better save offer is not the same as a harder cancel flow. Keep it to one clear offer, keep “cancel” easy to find, and let people leave if they want to. Regulators are increasingly focused on subscriptions that are hard to cancel, and one honest offer usually saves more revenue than a maze anyway.

The takeaway

A low churn rate isn’t the goal. Revenue from the subscribers you keep is. If your cancel flow leads with skips, your churn number may look great while your revenue quietly leaks out a month later.

This is the kind of thing we look at in every subscription retention engagement. If you want us to run this check on your account, it’s part of our free growth audit. You can also see our case studies.

Work with Bylders

Want this running in your account?

We’re a small, senior retention team for DTC brands on Klaviyo and subscription platforms like Recharge and Skio. The people who write these guides are the people who run client accounts.

Get started

Ready to Elevate Your Email Marketing?

Unlock your eCommerce potential with a personalized audit or a strategy call with our experts. Let's create a roadmap for your growth.

Get started

Ready to Elevate Your Email Marketing?

Unlock your eCommerce potential with a personalized audit or a strategy call with our experts. Let's create a roadmap for your growth.